Planning for Incapacity: Who Makes Decisions When You Can’t?

Estate planning is often thought of only in terms of what happens after death. But according to attorney Elissa Brewster, planning for incapacity is just as important—because life can change in an instant. Whether due to an accident, illness, or aging, the question of who makes decisions when someone cannot speak for themselves is one every family must address.

Why does incapacity planning matter?

Elissa Brewster explains that no one plans for an accident or sudden medical crisis. A simple drive to work could turn into a life-altering event. Families caught in these situations often face heartbreaking decisions without guidance.

Advanced directives and incapacity plans relieve loved ones of that burden. For example, individuals can specify whether they want to remain on a ventilator, designate organ donation preferences, or appoint someone they trust to make medical decisions. Having these choices documented provides clarity during emotional and stressful times.

What is the difference between medical and financial powers of attorney?

One of the most important tools in incapacity planning is the power of attorney.

  • A medical power of attorney allows a trusted person to make healthcare decisions if someone becomes incapacitated or unconscious.
  • A financial power of attorney authorizes another person to manage financial matters—such as paying bills, handling investments, or managing property—when the individual is unable to do so.

Brewster emphasizes that both are critical, as they cover different but equally important aspects of life.

What happens if no documents are in place?

Without a power of attorney or estate plan, decisions often default to the next of kin. That may be a spouse, parent, or adult child, depending on family circumstances. While this may sound straightforward, it often leads to conflict, court involvement, and unnecessary costs.

When financial decisions are left unresolved, courts must intervene under intestate laws. This process can drain resources and leave families with less inheritance. Brewster stresses a simple truth: families either spend money upfront to plan or spend more later in court fees and disputes.

How does guardianship protect children?

Guardianship becomes especially complex when minor children or children with special needs are involved. Brewster shares the concerns many parents have:

  • Who will raise their children if they are gone?
  • How will money be safeguarded for the children rather than diverted elsewhere?
  • Who will provide long-term care for an adult child with disabilities?

By naming guardians and trustees in advance, parents ensure their children are cared for by the right people and resources are properly managed.

How do you choose the right agent?

Appointing someone as power of attorney is a deeply personal decision. Brewster recommends selecting someone who is both trustworthy and capable of handling responsibilities.

Empathy and compassion matter, but so does financial literacy. Families should have open conversations with potential agents to confirm they are willing and prepared for the role. This avoids confusion and heartache later.

How can families prevent financial abuse?

Financial power of attorney grants significant authority, so safeguards are essential. If a family lacks someone trustworthy, Brewster suggests appointing a neutral third party such as an attorney or financial institution. This reduces the risk of abuse and ensures decisions align with the individual’s best interests.

Are estate planning documents permanent?

Contrary to common belief, estate planning documents are not set in stone. Brewster explains they are “living, breathing” documents that should be reviewed and updated regularly.

Life changes—such as marriage, divorce, the birth of a child, or the purchase of new property—should trigger a review of estate plans. However, once someone passes away, the documents become final and cannot be changed.

What is the first step to start incapacity planning?

For those who feel overwhelmed or unsure where to begin, Brewster’s advice is simple: reach out to an attorney. An estate planning lawyer will ask the right questions, walk through scenarios, and help create a plan tailored to family needs.

Having documents in place not only provides legal protection but also gives families peace of mind knowing they are prepared for life’s unexpected turns.

Conclusion

Planning for incapacity is not about expecting the worst—it is about protecting loved ones from uncertainty. By creating powers of attorney, naming guardians, and updating estate plans regularly, families can ensure their wishes are honored and their legacy preserved

Share

Get In Touch

Find Out How We Can Help You

“*” indicates required fields

Long Format Form

Connect with us

FIND OUT HOW WE CAN HELP YOU

REQUEST A CONSULTATION

Request a Consultation

Wide Format Form